Mass Torts: State of the Art

"Science Is The Belief In The Ignorance Of Experts"

The title is a quote from the speech, "What is Science?" given by Richard Feynman at the fifteenth annual meeting of the National Science Teachers Association in 1966. We thought of it today upon reading that an Italian court has found seven members of the country's National Commission for the Forecast and Prevention of Major Risks guilty of manslaughter. They were sentenced to lengthy prison terms. The crime? Failure to accurately gauge the risk of the L'Aquila earthquake of 2009.

If the convicted experts, leading seismologists and geologists, had been more humble about the limits of their knowledge some among the 309 killed by the quake might have fled when the tremors began. Instead they stayed, reassured by experts who publicly doubted that the tremors were harbingers of the devastating quake that would soon follow.

And if the court had understood that the business of science is to torment experts by seeking to falsify via observation and experiment the very theories that won them their renown it might have taken pity on the defendants. It might therefore also have understood that Nature has the last word and that she has a wicked habit of reminding us just how often even the most rational and widely held scientific beliefs are falsified when finally put to the test. If you need a more recent example, one from the past week, we suggest Gina Kolata's "Diabetes Study Ends Early With a Surprising Result" in the 10/19/2012 edition of The New York Times.

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
Comments (0) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease LLP
Columbus, Ohio
52 East Gay Street
PO Box 1008
Columbus, Ohio 43216-1008
Washington, D.C.
1909 K Street NW
Suite 900
Washington, D.C. 20006-1152
Cleveland, Ohio
1375 East Ninth Street
2100 One Cleveland Center
Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1724
Cincinnati, Ohio
301 East Fourth Street
Suite 3500, Great American Tower
PO Box 0236
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
Akron, Ohio
106 South Main Street
Suite 1100
Akron, Ohio 44308
Houston, Texas
700 Louisiana Street
Suite 4100
Houston, Texas 77002
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
500 Grant Street
Suite 4900
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219